Sentencing guidelines: local authority health and safety fines rise 1,870%
New research has shown fines from the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) have increased 74% in a year with local authority fines rising by a staggering 1,870%.
The report from global law firm Clyde & Co was taken from data obtained directly from the HSE and more than 300 local authorities. It shows a total value of fines increased to £73.2m in the first year of the new guidelines (year to 31 January 2017). This was against a sum of £35.4m in the previous 12 months.
From this sum, the HSE collected £61.6m in fines, and local authorities fines rose from £0.8m to £15.2m.
Impact of new guidelines
The new guidelines introduced in February 2016 saw tougher penalties for health and safety and corporate manslaughter offences. The scale of fines varies according to the turnover of the company. It potentially can exceed £20m for the worst cases of corporate manslaughter in the largest companies.
Head of compliance and strategic support in Clyde & Co’s safety, health and environment team, Rhian Greaves, said the new sentencing guidelines had made health and safety a ‘top priority for the boardroom’.
“Our research confirms what we have been seeing in practice – the new sentencing guidelines are biting hard,” she said.
“Good health and safety management is morally right. It also makes good business sense. When the potential reputational damage is added to the cost of the fine, it’s clear that health and safety failures are now a major business risks.”
Manufacturing and construction bear brunt
The study revealed manufacturing and construction sectors paid the most in fines as a result of health and safety breaches. The amount of fines increased to £13m from £7m – an increase of 83%.
Manufacturing alone was 37% of the overall total collected by the HSE this year with a sum of £22.8m overall, up from £11.4m in 2015/16 – A 99% rise. The highest fine was £3m for Cristal Pigment UK following two toxic gas cloud incidents.
Construction represented 21% of the total collected fines from the HSE this year. The highest fine imposed on the sector was £2.6m, ordered to be paid by Balfour Beatty.
More fines have exceeded £1m this year than in the previous 15 years combined.
Local Authority enforcement
Greaves described the local authority increase as ‘staggering’ – and said it ‘reinforced the dramatic effect the new sentencing regime is having on defendant organisations’.
The logistics sector has been hit the hardest by enforcement in the first year of the new guidelines. Warehousing organisations have paid out six times as much as the total figure for all local authority cases in the previous year.
Greaves said the large number of risks at distribution centres places them at the top of the local authorities’ agendas, and it was ‘arguably the highest risk industry within their jurisdiction’.
She said: “The logistics sector represents the most challenging risk for the local authority to manage. The public’s growing preference for internet shopping has seen huge distribution centres spring up nationwide. With high level racking, mechanical handling equipment and large numbers of employees, agency and gig economy workers, the area presents something of a perfect storm. ”
- Total fines collected by the HSE in 2016/17: £61,579,949.21
- Total fines collected by the HSE in 2015/16: £35,473,823
- Total fines collected by local authorities in 2016/17: £15,150,664
- Total fines collected by local authorities in 2015/16: £768,883
Sleep and Fatigue: Director’s Briefing
Fatigue is common amongst the population, but particularly among those working abnormal hours, and can arise from excessive working time or poorly designed shift patterns. It is also related to workload, in that workers are more easily fatigued if their work is machine-paced, complex or monotonous.
This free director’s briefing contains:
- Key points;
- Recommendations for employers;
- Case law;
- Legal duties.