Cameron bemoans health and safety for “holding people back” - news-content | SHP - Safety and Health Practitioner

Cameron bemoans health and safety for “holding people back”

05 October 2011

The prime minister has again described the application of health and safety laws as a barrier to enterprise, during his keynote speech to delegates at the Conservative Party conference in Manchester.
 
David Cameron’s comments appeared to contradict the Government’s recent lament at the use of health and safety as an excuse to hide unpopular decisions behind, and its insistence that correctly-applied health and safety legislation is a force for good.
 
He told delegates that the Conservatives valued community spirit and social action, adding: “That’s why we’re giving neighbourhoods new powers to take over the running of parks, playgrounds and pubs.”
 
However, in describing the obstacles to volunteering, he suggested that “the shadow of health and safety” is holding people back from such activities. He said: “I was told recently about a school that wanted to buy a set of highlighter pens. But, with the pens, came a warning: not so fast – make sure you comply with the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002, including plenty of fresh air and hand and eye protection. Try highlighting in all that!
 
“This isn’t how a great nation was built. Britannia didn't rule the waves with arm-bands on. So, the vetting and barring scheme – we’re scaling it back; CRB checks – we’re cutting them back. At long last, common sense is coming back to our country.”
 
IOSH reacted with disappointment to the speech. Said head of policy and public affairs, Richard Jones: “We think it’s a shame that the prime minister’s speech mistakenly cites health and safety as “holding people back” – the opposite is true!
 
“Good health and safety enables enterprise and volunteering to happen successfully and so helps ensure sustainability and growth. It’s all about good sense and proportionality and we simply don’t recognise the negative picture being painted here – it isn’t real health and safety.”
 
In August, Employment minister Chris Grayling conceded that it is misconceptions about and misapplication of health and safety legislation – rather than the laws themselves, or health and safety professionals – that have contributed to its negative image.


     
Tell A Colleague RSS feeds Print content Share

Add Comment

Neil
Sadly the country is currently being led by a PR man who lacks any values, he'll do anything for an applause, just like Theresa May's lie yesterday about the cat. The tories want to strip away the rights of the people and they are happy to lie as and when needed.

IOSH need to publicly condemn this statement as the utter rubbish it is, make this man look like the fool he is.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Nigel Bryson
Mr Cameron is about as accurate with his highlighter pens as the Home Secretary is blaming a cat for blocking a deportation. While he can make these facetious comments in front of the Party faithful, he has nothing to say on the increase in work related fatal accidents in the last year. No highlighting of the current HSE estimated annual 12,000 deaths due to exposure to substances at work. Yet again reality is ignored as soundbites are paraded as evidence!!

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Stephen Hartley
It's about time the PM got his facts straight and stopped adding to the H&S mythology. Responsible leader in Government? I think not

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
OldNick
Disgraceful! Utterly disgraceful!

An easy smokescreen to attempt to put people off the real reasons why the country's industry is in the state it is. Ask the folks at Bombardier and other industries in a similar position if they believe the reason for their job losses is down to H&S.

Hopefully Mr Cameron will never have to deal with the consequences of a serious workplace accident within his family.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Nigel Hammond
I despair. It suggests to me that they really haven't got a grip on the economy if they have to divert attention on to phantom ElfnSafety stories. I wonder what proportion of the population will actually believe the highlighter pens story? He'll be trying to remove COSHH next!

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Barbara Evans
I don't think Cameron is contradicting himself...the example he gives clearly illustrates H&S being over zealously applied, PPE with highlighter pens, please give me a break! It's not the law that's the problem, it's how it's being applied that's causing the confusion.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Coxy
Oh Dear, once again the PM gets it horribly wrong, ill informed statements such as this feeds this perception of us all being killjoys and detached from the real world etc etc, yes Mr Grayling did (correctly) concede it was misconceptions & misapplication Of H&S legislation only for Mr Cameron to once again complete a U turn.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Andy Collier
I do feel the negative message will not work, Mr Cameron cites with nostalgia that we were once a great nation with common sense. We also had a population of people who accepted responsibility and accountability who were diligent and concientious not how they are now just in it for themselves and damn evryone else, this is why our laws have been misapplied and misinterpreted. Don't jump on the health and safety bandwagon Mr Cameron, try and instill some pride, some real British values !

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Ed
It's clear that the Prime minster's remarks are foolish and show he has little or no understanding or can't be bothered finding out. I'm pleased to hear that IOSH think "it's a shame". Has anyone from IOSH actually got hold of him rather than a spokesperson and tried to enlighten him? After all IOSH is the voice of health and safety

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Malcolm Griffiths
Whatever Mr Jones says, David Cameron is right, whether it is directly through the fact of the regulations or (more commonly) through the extreme interpretation of those rules. The rules play directly into the hands of the councils and other public bodies, with their 'job creation scheme' mentality and their ignorance of real risk. More importantly, they do not need to take any account of cost because all that is passed back to the tax payer.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Steve
I think its time to look for another job!! I don't mean that complete ***** (although what a good idea that would be) I mean me!
I have a hard enough job as it is trying to protect people and convince then that their safety matters, without the Prime minister of this country decrying it. What a great excuse they all have now!!!!

Posted on 06/10/11 12:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
mike
Mr Cameron, can you plase prodive the name of the School?

Posted on 06/10/11 12:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Barrie Jones
For a long time I have been appalled by the stupidity of some of the health
and safety "professional". People expected to wear ear defenders when there is little noise, wearing plastic hats (safety helmets) when ther is no chance of an object falling on them or the only objects weigh tons and recently a television program where the presenters were wearing high vis. jackets and plastic hats where sensible safety gear would have been a breathing mask and a life jacket. I for support Mr. Cameron.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Alan Irwin
The PM seems to have adopted a blantant disregard for the safety of workers and young people and takes every opportunity to make a joke of health and safety. Safe workers are competent, efficient and above all productive workers. Unemployment, government cuts, no pay rises are some of the issues holding people back. Defence cuts are why we do not rule the waves anymore. Do we hear the PM mention that? The PM is the joke not health and safety.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Stewart Hussey (CMIOSH, AIEMA)
For God's sake is it beyond IOSH, ROSPA and all the other August safety bodies to refrain from using the soft, moralising, persuasive but obviously ineffective approach to MPs, which only results in more hand wringing and despair because they just don't get it, and simply provide the real, basic data on work related deaths, injuries and ill health and the costs to a struggling economy - they only understand numbers, not moral arguments.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Rod Tripplet
Richard Jones is quite right, good H & S management does help business grow; emphasis on the word good. Unfortunately IOSH doesn't promote good H & S, as a member's only organisation it churns out people with a NEBOSH certificate kidding them they are H & S professionals, when they haven't even started to learn. What we need is an organisatin led by good practical people who are interested in promoting H & S, and not just themselves. Currently David Cameron is right. H & S is stiffling business.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:05.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Mike Koumi
for the leader of a Country to make such dangerous and un-substanfiated statements for politcal popularity is nothing short of disgraceful. Good H&S assists not obstructs.

Posted on 06/10/11 12:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Massimo Verdi
Did anyone really expect anything different – just another vox pop to appease the ‘informed majority’

The sad thing is that maybe, just maybe, the statement is true – I hope not (it could be just another ‘cat walk’!)

Posted on 06/10/11 12:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Nigel Hammond
So, do you actually believe his highlighter pen story then? :-|

Posted on 06/10/11 12:25 in reply to Malcolm Griffiths.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
mark
Putting the "Great" into Britain occured in 1701. A time when we traded in slaves, invaded other countries taking their resources as our own, imposed servitude over the wishes of entire nations, sent boys up chimneys, press-ganged men to their death on horrendous ships, when London swam in gin as mothers tried to forget their misery, where if you went to court you were on your own against rich men, when women had no vote.
Live in the UK now and be asked a banal question about COSHH? Yes please.

Posted on 06/10/11 13:58.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Showing 1 - 20 of 47 results.
Items per Page
Page of 3

 

 
 

 

 
 
 
 

United Business Media