The MAIB’s Annual Report published in June highlighted the issue of unsafe pilot ladders, a concern that has been regularly voiced by the industry. Here, Inspector of Marine Accidents, Bill Evans, explains the importance of the pilot ladder.
Example of a non-conforming pilot ladder arrangement
In 2021, the branch received almost 200 reports about substandard pilot ladders. Of those, 87% of the ladders were rigged incorrectly (image, right) and the remainder were observed by the marine pilot as being materially defective (Figure 1, below).
Fortunately, serious accidents have been rare, but the potential for injury and even loss of life clearly exists.
To mark Maritime Safety Week, HSE inspector Bill Evans has highlighted the key issues surrounding pilot ladders and his views on why they are so important.
What did you do before you became an MAIB Inspector?
“Like many seafarers in the 1970s, I left school at 16 and joined the Merchant Navy as a deck officer, spending the next 8 years working all over the world on board a variety of ferries and dry cargo vessels. In the 1980s, I joined the Royal Navy and, during my 30 years’ service there, worked on every type of warship, from patrol boat to aircraft carrier. My last job before taking up my current role was to oversee the safe operation of five military ports, three in the UK and two overseas. It was while undertaking this role that I saw and successfully applied for the job of MAIB Inspector; I started work here in 2017.”
Why is improving pilot ladder safety so important?
“Marine pilots play a critical role in the safe operation of any harbour, where they guide almost every vessel in and out of the port. However, while the size and technological complexity of ships has increased, marine pilots still embark and disembark moving vessels by using a rope pilot ladder. The pilot transfer is a hazardous operation, so it is absolutely essential that these ladders are correctly rigged and their use properly supervised by the crew.”
What are the things you should look out for when inspecting the safety of a pilot ladder?
The crew must inspect the pilot ladder before and after its use to verify that it is in good condition:
How do you rig a pilot ladder so it is safe?
“To rig a pilot ladder correctly, it must be secured to strong points on the ship’s deck by a rope stopper attached to the ladder’s side ropes. Some of the reported incidents of substandard rigging have included the use of shackles or guardrails, which should never be used to secure the ladder. When a combination of accommodation and pilot ladder is being used, the lower platform of the accommodation ladder must be horizontal and secured to the ship’s side so that the pilot can safely transition between the two. On some larger container vessels, a trapdoor arrangement is used, in which case the pilot ladder must extend above the platform to ensure that the marine pilot can safely transfer. Finally, it is imperative that the pilot ladder is supervised by a qualified officer when in use, ready to take action if things go wrong. The ABP poster is an excellent guide as to what is acceptable and what is not (Figures 2a to d).”
