Football clubs ban vuvuzelas over safety concerns - news-content | SHP - Safety and Health Practitioner

Football clubs ban vuvuzelas over safety concerns

21 July 2010

Several English football clubs have banned vuvuzelas from their grounds on match days on account of safety concerns.

Tottenham Hotspur, Liverpool and Arsenal are the highest-profile clubs to announce that the plastic horns will not be allowed inside their stadia. The instrument came to prominence during the recent FIFA World Cup in South Africa where it was described as a symbol of African culture. But television stations airing the matches were flooded with complaints from viewers about the ‘droning’ noise created by thousands of fans continuously blowing the instrument during the games.

A number of fans have called for vuvuzelas to be banned at all football grounds across the country, claiming the noise could pose risks to public safety. Spurs banned the horns amid fears that the noise could prevent fans from hearing safety announcements. A statement on the club’s official website said: “We are concerned that the presence of the instruments within the stadium poses unnecessary risks and could impact on the ability of all supporters to hear any emergency safety announcements.”

West Ham United have also introduced a ban stating that the instruments could potentially be used as a weapon. A club statement said: “Under the current health and safety regulations at the stadium, which already disallow musical bands, we would not allow them (vuvuzelas) into the stadium as they could be considered a weapon.”

The HSE would not be drawn on whether it supports calls for a widespread ban, but acknowledged that the horns could potentially cause hearing damage. An HSE spokesman said: “As with any source of high sound levels, vuvuzelas could potentially cause hearing damage under certain circumstances, and where there is such a risk we would expect an employer to take proportionate, sensible measures to protect their staff.

 Anybody concerned about noise levels in their workplace should visit our website for advice.”

One club which will be allowing fans to bring vuvuzelas to matches is Oxford United, who won promotion back to the Football League in May. The club’s communications officer, Chris Williams, told SHP: “We will not be banning the vuvuzela at the start of the season but will monitor the situation as we go along. Obviously, the noise is what people focused on at the World Cup but there may be safety issues as well.”


     
Tell A Colleague RSS feeds Print content Share

Add Comment

Brad Kowalski
Doubt it'll be a problem at little clubs like Oxford as the gates they get aren't big enough. The pressure for the ban is always going to come from high-profile clubs and those that are featured on the box!

Posted on 21/07/10 05:00.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
SHP Editor
I think you will find Oxford United took 33,000 fans to Wembley in May in a game shown live on Sky. The club was also used as an example by the FA as part it's official World Cup bid after attracting a 10,000 attendance for a midweek game when the club was in the Conference.

As you might have guessed SHP's web editor is a fan of the mighty Yellows!

Posted on 21/07/10 05:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
CW
Good to see Oxford and most other clubs are not reacting to the pathetic hysteria created by some people. These things won't catch on enough to be a safety concern...ok maybe they will at Millwall and West Ham for other reasons!

Posted on 21/07/10 22:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Razor
I wouldn't ban people bring these instruments of doom to the ground. I would simply seek permission from the courts to be allowed to set them on fire.

You wouldn't blow one of these things in a church so don't blow them in grounds. Football is a religion too!

Posted on 21/07/10 22:03.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Ian Bennett
Oh Come on!

"On Safety grounds". How gutless, why not come out and just say that so many people loath them that we are not having vuvuzelas in the place. let's not blacken the name of health and safety with such lilly livered statements.

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Andy N
Safety getting blamed for banning a harmless plastic toy at football matches, if clubs want to ban them because it'll annoy the TV companies, then let them say so.
The bans have nothing to do with safety, or they would have to ban singing and chanting too.

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Steve Galvin
So we cannot even blow our own trumpets now - are we not offending the African Culture by our lack of inclusion of their culture? Mmmm...

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Trundlebug
Banning vuvuzelas because of elf'n'safety?

Nothing to do with them being a b****ing irritating racket then..

Could be used as a weapon, a bit like the deadly pop bottle, which we all know is lethal in the hands of irresponsible people (especially when someone has shaken it up before you open it)...

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
T Adams
As an Arsenal fan and season ticket holder I suppose I ought to point out (before someone else does) that its not very surprising that something which creates noise has been banned from the Emirates Stadium....

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33 in reply to Razor.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
RK
Only in this country could people enjoying themselves be frowned upon by the safety authorities at football grounds. No drinking, no smoking, no musical instruments, NO STANDING.....
I'm sure at some point "No Over Celebration" will creep into the stands too. After all there was about 500 people injured in the stands when Mikey Owen scored that late, late, LATE winner against Man City last season. Now surely that must be looked upon as a high risk for injury. Maybe they should ask Man Utd to stop scoring late goals as it presents a safety risk in the ground???

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Vivienne Michael, CEO, Deafness Research UK
These tuneless trumpets can emit sounds in excess of 130 decibels (equivalent to
a jumbo jet taking off) and as the national charity concerned with deafness
research and related issues, Deafness Research UK would like to see an urgent
ban on these instruments.

We urge other football clubs to silence the vuvuzela before it causes permanent hearing damage. For facts and guidance about hearing loss and deafness-related conditions, e-
mail info@deafnessresearch.org.uk or call free on 0808 808 2222.

Posted on 21/07/10 23:33.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Razor
Finally some support. All hail Ms Michael good luck on your quest to ban this monstrosity of an instrument.

Posted on 21/07/10 23:37 in reply to Vivienne Michael, CEO, Deafness Research UK.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Tim Southam
What a load of ........!

It doesn't make any sense to ban these items of fun under the grounds of "Safety" - weapons, noise, drown out safety announcements. we are becoming risk averse and stopping people having some fun. On a serious side, we are happy to allow "ipods" and mp3 players delivering up to 130db in each ear without any action against the manufacturers. We are also allowed to put high power speakers in small cars that will cause hearing damage.

Safety is a personal construction, an individual view. it has nothing to do with a hazard or risk management. The legislation it is quite clear and precise - unfortunately many people try to ban things based on little or no knowledge of the real regulations - conkers comes to mind and having to wear light eye protection.

Lets get real and start enjoying life again.

Posted on 22/07/10 02:14.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Keith
Why is everything always banned on "health & safety" grounds? I found the noise from vuvuzelas at the work cup really annoying, and that is the issue rather than a health issue. So why don't clubs just come out and ban them because they don't want them spoiling spectactors pleasure instead of hiding behind "health & safety fears" Another Myth being formed methinks!!

Posted on 22/07/10 02:14.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
RK
How many decibels are there when 70,000 supporters jump up screaming their heads off when an important goal is scored?
Just curious as I go to the football all the time and I get a ringing in my ears after a goal sends the crowd into hysteria. Am I damaging my hearing??

Posted on 22/07/10 02:14 in reply to Vivienne Michael, CEO, Deafness Research UK.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Amanda Bellamy
As well as effecting people's hearing, the noise from vuvuzelas could have an impact on the players and their ability to communicate among themselves effectively. We raised this on the IEHF website a couple of weeks ago, see http://iehf.org/articles/receiving-end-vuvuzelas

Posted on 22/07/10 02:14.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Linda
I agree with Vivienne, it is the level of noise that these things produce that is the issue here and i for one would not want to be next to one for the duration of a match let a lone a statdium full as i quite cheerish my hearing. That said banning them should not be the first action, we are not out to spoli peoples enjoyment are we? a quite word (pardon the pun) with the importer/manufacturer about restricting the noise they are capable of producing to a resonable level would solve the problem surely?

Posted on 22/07/10 02:14 in reply to Vivienne Michael, CEO, Deafness Research UK.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
SC
There is interest elsewhere in Europe: Institute for Occupational Safety and Health of the German Social Accident Insurance (IFA) measured noise levels. At a distance of half a meter they recorded levels up to 100 Dezibel (A). At a distance of 10 cm levels were 125 bis 130 Dezibel (A). The IFA concluded that the use of vuvuzelas could lead to permanent damage for hearing for amateurs and workers in sports areas, and other places were they are used. They also recommended the use of hearing protection, for example adequate and appropriate ear plugs, and for workers to keep a distance of five meters when not wearing hearing protection.
IFA website (in German): http://www.dguv.de/ifa/de/akt/889_vuvuzelas/index.jspand
Source: http://osha.europa.eu/en/news/de-vuvuzela-noise-can-affect-your-hearing

Posted on 22/07/10 02:14.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
May
Yet another "for health and safety reasons" cop out. No wonder people think safety is to blame for everything wrong in the world!!!! Can't they just admit "we're banning them coz they make an awful, annoying sound"?!?!!?

Posted on 22/07/10 02:52.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Graham Windram
There are too many daft bans in the name of “Health and Safety” just because a killjoy has decided they simply do not like something.
So a spurious excuse is made up, yes we know its an awful droning noise and yes it is noisy . But we don't ban Glastonbury or other noisy pop concerts where the noise generated is going to be above the thresholds. What next ban people from going to pop concerts if they are not wearing ear defenders. Get real “Health and Safety” is important and is there to protect, not be a simple excuse to bans things we don't like!!!!!!

Posted on 22/07/10 04:22.

Post Reply Post Reply Top Top
Showing 1 - 20 of 27 results.
Items per Page
Page of 2

 

 
 

 

 
 
 
 

United Business Media