How will artificial intelligence impact on our jobs?
In her fourth article in her series on artificial intelligence, Helen Beers looks at how making machines smart might impact on our jobs and considers whether it will put anyone out of work as a result.
Catch up on Helen’s previous articles on what artificial intelligence is, the current trends and future developments, and what’s enabling and hindering artificial intelligence.
For centuries, people have been afraid that technology will take their jobs. For example, in the 16th Century, Elizabeth I believed a machine for knitting stockings would bring ruin to her subjects by depriving them of their employment. The inventor believed it would liberate hand knitters from their drudgery; but was denied a patent, forced to move to France and died in poverty. Some 150 years later, weavers and manufacturers conspired against an inventor of a shuttle that doubled weaving productivity. This inventor was also forced to move to France and died in poverty (seemed to be an occupational hazard for inventors!).
Today the fear that technology will take our jobs still exists, with some commentators suggesting that AI (or machine intelligence) could lead to chronic unemployment. In reality, based on census results over the past 140 years, technology has actually created more jobs than it has destroyed. But, what is the situation today? Some believe that the impact of technology on society is now different from in the past. This is due to the increased scope and pace of technological change, and the unequal sharing of technological benefits (with only some workers gaining as a result of the change).
The expectation is that we will see three broad types of workplace change: displacement, people losing their current jobs; augmentation (in which current jobs are done better with new technology); and the creation of new jobs. It is likely that new sectors, products and services will create jobs and there will be new types of interaction between workers and machines.
In making a judgement about the extent to which AI could take our jobs, the challenge is appreciating how jobs will change. To date, technological advances have mostly had an impact on ‘blue-collar’ jobs, but as technology advances further, it threatens to impact on ‘white-collar’ work as well. For example, AI is being used by the legal profession to substitute for tasks performed by paralegals, contract and patent lawyers (AI is scanning thousands of legal briefs and precedents to perform document review and to assist in pre-trial research).
It’s likely that a large number of medium skilled jobs will disappear, and new ‘digital’ jobs will be created (involving tasks such as sorting, entering and filtering data; cleaning forums and monitoring images).
It has been estimated that 35% of UK jobs are at high risk of automation in the next 10 to 20 years. Jobs most likely to be automated via ‘computerisation’ have been suggested to be those in transport and logistics, office support (e.g. receptionists and security guards), along with many in sales and services (e.g. cashiers and accountants). Other suggestions are that the wholesale and retail sector has the highest number of jobs at risk of automation. However, it’s important to point out that any estimate of the impact of AI on jobs has limitations. For example, calculations may be made from a purely technological view point, without consideration of other factor that may influence change.
Machines will continue to take on more repetitive and laborious tasks. In fact, software already exists that can automate non-routine tasks, by dividing these into smaller tasks, initially automating the routine parts and recruiting freelance workers to deliver the non-routine parts. Over time the software monitors the workers and learns from them, thus being able to carry out many of the non-routine tasks, and thus replace the workers.
The extent to which an individual ‘gains or loses’ from automation will depend on their level of skill and whether they are a substitute or a complement to the machine. Whilst it is challenging to anticipate the types of jobs that will emerge in the future, one characteristic that they will share is that of being significantly more skilled than most of the jobs in the past.
The influence which AI (and in particular machine learning) is likely to have on the skills required for the future, along with the tasks which AI is unlikely to replace is the subject of our next article in this series.
©Crown Copyright 2016, Health and Safety Executive