Author Bio ▼

A journalist with 13 years of experience on trade publications covering construction, local government, property, pubs, and transport.
July 7, 2017

Get the SHP newsletter

Daily health and safety news, job alerts and resources

In court

Full case: Cotswolds-based activity firm cleared of charges after girl fell 10m

Gloucester Crown Court

Gloucester Crown Court

A Cotwolds-based activity centre, Head 4 Heights, has been cleared of health and safety failings after a 10 year old girl  fell from a 10m platform and suffered serious injuries.

The trial heard from instructor Andy Russell, a former employee, and managing director, Rod Baber, regarding the incident which happened in July 2015 at the centre in Cotswold Water Park.

The girl, who could not be named, was attached to a three-loop spreader bar, which should have held her weight as she jumped from the platform in a simulated free-fall.

But half-way up the ladder to the platform she back came down, and when she re-ascended Russell had not secured the bar correctly, causing her to fall and break her wrist and dislocate her elbow.

Russell had mistakenly set up the device like a different product also used by the company.

New device

Health and safety consultant Stephen Flanagan, who is an accident expert at amusement parks and leisure resorts, told Gloucester Crown Court the device was new to the firm, and was introduced in ‘an uncontrolled way’ that ‘led to a failure to identify the increased risk of human error which would result.’

He said that having two separate devices – one with a single loop and one with a triple loop – was like using the wrong credit card and putting the wrong PIN into an ATM as a result.

Therefore it gave the ‘potential for the operator to use the wrong routine’.

Primary issue

But company owner Baber outlined safety was ‘always our primary issue’ to the prosecution, local authority, Cotswold District Council.

He said the firm undertook daily and monthly inspections, documented operational inspections as well as annual inspections. It also did independent inspections, with files going back to 2003.

Baber also outlined how the firm had a ‘near miss book’ which provided the team with learning for the future.

Responsibility

Russell also said the incident was entirely his responsibility, and the company was not at fault. The firm was standing trial for failing to make a suitable and sufficient risk assessment and failing to ensure that people were not put at risk.

Prosecutor Bernard Thorogood asked Russell if a second instructor to check harnesses would have assisted with safety, or if using different coloured straps would have helped.

He admitted that a second person whose sole job it was to check equipment would have assisted in safety checks, but stressed that the accident was his responsibility and was the result of human error.

Excellent culture

A psychologist, Dr Tim Marsh, supported the defence, stating there was an ‘excellent’ organisational culture within Head 4 Heights.

The local authority had claimed there was not enough paperwork on risk assessment, but Marsh said the ‘hands on’ approach was ‘entirely appropriate’.

He said it was ‘clear what they had to do’ and was too simple a task to have any benefit from being written down.

Marsh claimed a number of organisations had good paperwork but not actual safety ‘on the ground’ – or ‘safety as done not as said’.

Verdict

The firm was cleared of all charges by the jury who deliberated for three and a half hours on the case, acquitting them of the two alleged offences of failing to ensure public safety.

The trail lasted 11 days.

Farming company fined £320k after a man died from fall

A company involved in fruit and vegetable production has been fined £320,000 after a man was killed at a site in Burscough.

Roofing firm fined total of £880k after two workers injured

A roofing company has been fined a total of £881,000 after two workers were seriously injured during two separate incidents.

Entertainment company fined after worker dies from fall

A company in the entertainment industry has been fined £16,000 following the death of a worker.

Companies fined after labourer fractures skull

Two companies have been fined £46,000 in total after a labourer from Runcorn fractured his skull.

Dockside company sentenced after worker seriously injured on trawler

A dockside warehousing company has been fined £127,500 after a worker fell 25ft through an open hatch on a trawler which had no edge protection.

Haulage company fined £100k after worker dies from injuries

A haulage company in Wales has been fined £100,000 after a worker fell from a loading bay and died.

Construction company fined after bricklayer fractures skull

A construction company has been fined £12,000 after a Shropshire bricklayer fell through a stairwell opening and fractured his skull.

Business park operator fined after worker injured in fall

A Runcorn business park operator has been fined £13,000 after a worker fell more than 13 feet through a fragile roof.

Teenager fell more than 20 feet through roof of Bodmin dairy farm

A Bodmin dairy farm has been fined more than £60,000 after one of its workers sustained multiple injuries when he fell more than 20 feet through a roof on to a concrete floor.

Company fined after worker fractures back and ribs following fall

A company has been fined after an employee fractured his back and ribs following a fall from a house in Frodsham, Cheshire.

The Safety Conversation Podcast: Listen now!

The Safety Conversation with SHP (previously the Safety and Health Podcast) aims to bring you the latest news, insights and legislation updates in the form of interviews, discussions and panel debates from leading figures within the profession.

Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Google Podcasts, subscribe and join the conversation today!

Related Topics

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments