Journalist, SHP Online

August 2, 2016

Get the SHP newsletter

Daily health and safety news, job alerts and resources

Network Rail worker was using “hopelessly inaccurate” diagram

Network Rail has been fined £130,000 after a worker was hit by a 25,000 volt power surge while repairing an overhead line near Ardrossan South Beach station in 2009. The court heard that Network Rail had provided crews carrying out the repairs with a “hopelessly inaccurate” work diagram.

David McDermott suffered “catastrophic injuries” in the incident resulting in significant loss of function and years of surgery.

He had been with a colleague in a mobile platform fixing an isolated section of cable when he touched a live wire and was struck by a 25,000 volt power surge.

Sheriff Alistair Watson described Mr McDermott’s injuries as “catastrophic” and said no penalty would set a price or value on the pain and suffering he continued to endure.

Network Rail was fined £130,000 after it admitted failing to provide safe working documentation and ensuring work was only done on isolated sections of line.

The sheriff added: “The obvious failure in the system, which is perhaps self-evident, is the fact that the schematic or diagram used as an essential guide for those involved in the repair operation was hopelessly inaccurate for a considerable length of time, despite it potentially being an issue of life and death importance.

“It appears to have been in continuous use by those who entrusted their safety to their employer. Put bluntly, this meant that a serious accident of this type, while perhaps not inevitable, was eventually highly foreseeable.”

Sheriff Watson also voiced his “grave concern” over the delay of seven years for the case to reach court, which prosecutors blamed on technical hitches involving statements and different agents being involved in the case.

Kilmarnock Sheriff Court heard the firm has since improved working systems.

Free Download: Skin care best practice eBook

According to HSE, skin disorders affect 40% of workers at some point in their career. Occupational skin disorders (OSDs) are amongst the most significant health and safety issues facing industry leaders across the world. This whitepaper from Deb puts occupational skin disorders in the spotlight to offer guidance on how employers can take control through a preventative skin care programme.

Discover how you can take control here.

Skin care best practice

Related Topics

Leave a Reply

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
peter gotch

These health and safety prosecutions are almost routinely taking MUCH too long to get to Court.


Outside of the oil and gas industry, there are still some outdated and dangerous practices and people working everyday with little or no HSE guidance from management and often management propagate the failures that are still avoidably injuring workers.