A national crane hire company has been sentenced for failings that led to the death of two men as a crane collapsed in London in September 2006.
Southwark Crown Court heard crane operator Jonathan Cloke, 37, died after falling from the crane as it collapsed. Michael Alexa, 23, a member of the public, was crushed by the falling crane, fatally injuring him.
The court heard how sections of the tower crane, which was on a housing development in Thessaly Road, Battersea, separated when 24 bolts failed due to metal fatigue.
The 24 bolts were a significant safety feature on the crane’s slew ring, which connected the mast (tower) to the slew turret. This allows the arms of the crane (jib) to rotate through 360 degrees. When the bolts failed the slew turret and jib separated from the mast and fell to the ground.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation into the incident found Falcon Crane Hire Ltd did not investigate a similar incident which happened nine weeks before, when the bolts failed on the same crane and had to be replaced.
HSE found the company had an inadequate system to manage the inspection and maintenance of their fleet of cranes. Their process to investigate the underlying cause of components’ failings was also inadequate. It told the court the particular bolts were a safety critical part of the crane. The court also heard the bolts failing previously was an exceptional and significant occurrence, which should have been recognised by Falcon Crane Hire.
Falcon Crane Hire Ltd were fined £750,000 and ordered to pay costs of £100,000 for breaching Sections 2 and 3 of the Health and Safety at Work Etc Act.
Lilliana Alexa, Michael’s mother, said on behalf of her family: “Michael was a lovely son, a wonderful big brother and a devoted father. His son has had to grow up without the love and support of Michael, who adored him. He was denied that opportunity because his life was taken away and with his, ours too.
“The memories of that day will never leave our family. We heard the crash and felt the ground shake. I found Michael and it’s an image that haunts my nightmares. If only we had stopped to chat or parked the car somewhere else he would still be alive. We know we are not to blame but it does not stop us all feeling guilt.
“We cannot comprehend how our beloved son, brother, father and friend who was so full of live has gone. The whole crane industry must learn from our tragedy and the devastation it has caused. We do not want another family to endure the same pain of losing their child.”
Mike Wilcock, HSE Head of Operations, said: “Jonathan and Michael’s deaths were tragic, needless and entirely avoidable. These two men need not have died had Falcon Crane Hire taken the right, decisive action when the bolts failed the first time. The company fell far short of its health and safety obligation.”
Falcon Crane Hire said in a statement: “Falcon Crane Hire Ltd would like to express thier sincere condolences to the families and friends of Mr Cloke and Mr Alexa who died tragically in the crane accident in Battersea in September 2006.
“The company regards health and safety as being of paramount importance in its operations and it has taken every step to ensure that procedures adopted in the pursuance of its operations are conducted as safely and efficiently as possible.
“Falcon has, throughout this very long investigation, co-operated fully with all authoirities and has been determined to understand fully the causes of this tragic accident and learn all safety lessons.
“Following the incident, the company has examined all its procedures. Where lessons could be learnt, they have been, where different methods of work could be used, they have been implemented and where higher level of skills could be attained, the ncessary training has been given.”
The Safety Conversation with SHP (previously the Safety and Health Podcast) aims to bring you the latest news, insights and legislation updates in the form of interviews, discussions and panel debates from leading figures within the profession.
Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Google Podcasts, subscribe and join the conversation today!
can anybody advise when and where the full report can be viewed/ downloaded as this is an important issue for all crane users around the world.
[…] Link to the full report at Safety and Health Practitioner website <– click […]