Smell of success: subconscious safety influencers
Dominic Cooper explains how behaviours are grounded in physical sensations like temperature, colour and smell, and how this is linked to improving safety.
Safety Culture research[i] shows that psychological factors, observable behaviours, and the prevailing situation are inextricably linked; what occurs in one of these elements, impacts the other two. Used extensively in industry, this work reveals that the best way to optimise safety behaviour is to optimise the situation[ii].
Nudge theory[iii] uses this knowledge to adapt situations to get people to engage in desired behaviours. A successful nudge is where any aspect of the environment influences a desired behaviour and makes that action more likely to occur: a good safety example is the use of radar-equipped speed signs that tell drivers their own actual speed, this leads to substantially more drivers slowing down than simple speed limit signs.
Taking the nudge concept a bit further, Thalma Lobel[iv] a psychology professor, explored how physical and abstract concepts are linked in the brain. It appears our minds cannot work separately from the physical world: she aptly demonstrates that our emotions, thoughts, and behaviours are subconsciously grounded in physical sensations like temperature, texture, weight, colour, and smell. Given this fact, are there opportunities to use this knowledge to better improve safety in small, subtle, simple, and cheap ways? The following suggests ways we may do so.
Temperature: When people feel cold they tend to feel more negative about things; when they feel warm they tend to be more receptive towards new ideas and other people, but if they feel too hot they tend to be more aggressive. To influence others during safety meetings / toolbox talks, etc., it appears we should ensure a room is comfortably warm, with warm drinks (e.g. Tea/Coffee) provided as the audience are more likely to be receptive to safety ideas, and the speaker is more likely to be trusted.
Texture: Because we tend to equate rough / smooth or hard / soft textures with bad / good respectively, our perceptions and attitudes tend to be more positive when we are in contact with smooth and/or soft surfaces or objects. Perhaps, when trying to sell safety ideas and changes, we should provide soft chairs for people to sit on, so people are more likely to be receptive and keep an open mind.
Weight: The heavier a book, clipboard, stationary, etc., the more it influences our opinion about value, importance, and seriousness of the content. This shows that our judgement of importance is subconsciously linked to the concept of physical weight. In safety, we could use this to emphasise the importance of Rules & Procedures, etc., by printing them on thicker paper or presenting it in a heavier folder.
Colour: It is well known that colours subconsciously affect our perceptions, behaviour, and physical performance; for example, red clothing signals power and authority, whereas white exudes positivity and goodness. This knowledge suggests safety professionals should stop wearing red coveralls and/or red hard hats, as they are perceived to be displaying their dominance, power, and authority. Potentially, this could be creating unnecessary barriers that block communications between themselves and those they are trying to influence. Conversely, people wearing white shirts and hard hats, etc., tend to be seen as more helpful, and therefore, more influential. Similarly, brighter / lighter working environments lead to greater feelings of well-being and better performance than darker gloomy ones. Using lighter / brighter venues for training courses, safety meetings, toolbox talks etc., could lead to much greater willing involvement of attendees.
Smell: It is similarly well-known that smells affect people’s emotions, behaviour, and judgements. However, less familiar is that smells associated with cleaning (e.g. citrus) cause people to clean more. This has obvious implications for housekeeping, typically a problem area in many companies. Placing citrus smelling air-fresheners around a workplace may significantly increase the likelihood that people will be motivated to clean up after themselves without prompting.
Winning over people’s hearts & minds to the safety cause has always been difficult. Given there are cheap, cheerful, and simple solutions that could help smooth the path, we would be foolish to ignore them. By harnessing the untapped power of subtle environmental and physical cues on our subconscious, we can ‘nudge’ people to behave in desired ways to help improve safety. The solutions offered are not a panacea for the all the ills in safety, but surely they must be worth trying.
[i] Cooper, M.D. (2000). ‘Towards a Model of Safety Culture’. Safety Science, Vol 32 (6), 111-136.
[ii] Cooper, M.D. & Finley, L.J. (2103). Strategic Safety Culture Roadmap. BSMS Franklin, IN
[iii] Thaler, R. & Sunstein, C. (2008). Nudge. Penguin Books.
[iv] Lobel, T. (2014) Sensation: The New Science of Physical Intelligence. Icon Books, London.
According to Barbour, almost a third of workers have been bullied and half of women, and a fifth of men, have been sexually harassed at work. Bullying and harassment is offensive or insulting behaviour that makes someone feel intimidated. It may involve the abuse of power by one person over another, or it can involve groups of people.
This free employee factsheet contains:
- What is bullying and harassment?
- The impact of bullying;
- The role of an employer;
- Advice for combatting bullying;
- Actions to take;
- Sources of help and information.