Editor, UBM

September 4, 2015

Get the SHP newsletter

Daily health and safety news, job alerts and resources

Firm fined over “entirely foreseeable accident with fatal consequences”

IMAGE Baling machine

Baling machine

A waste recycling firm has been sentenced after admitting safety failings related to the death of Simon Brook, 50, a father of six, at its premises in Batley. It is believed Mr Brook was attempting to clear a blockage when he fell into the baling machine’s hopper, which automatically restarted.

Bradford Crown Court heard that on 17 August 2012, Mr Brook, an employee of Gwynn Davies-McTiffin Ltd was found lying seriously injured at the bottom of a horizontal baling machine.

His legs had been partially severed inside the machine and had to be amputated by a doctor at the scene. He died two days later.

The court heard though there were no witnesses to the incident, it seems likely the deceased was fatally injured when he fell into the baling machine’s hopper while clearing a blockage. A steel pole was found in the chamber, suggesting that Mr Brook had been using the pole to clear a blockage at the time of the accident.

HSE said its investigation found that as the machine was operational at the time, and it is likely that Mr Brook falling into the hopper cleared the blockage, causing the machine to automatically restart.

HSE served a Prohibition Notice on the company on the day of the incident prohibiting use of the baler involved due to the guarding deficiencies allowing access to dangerous parts. An Improvement Notice was also served requiring the company to provide systems of work for all foreseeable interventions on the baler.

IMAGE Simon-Brook

Simon Brook

HSE told the court that failings at the company’s premises in Batley were systemic. Health and safety management systems fell far short of what was required with management failing to ensure that long standing actions from risk assessments were implemented or that safe working practices for clearing blockages were put in place.

The court heard that blockages occurred every shift at the plant, with employees describing various unsafe methods of clearing blockages in the hopper of the baler. These included standing on the top platform, leaning over the side and prodding the blockage with a stick, climbing over the side of the machine and standing on the conveyor belt at the top of the hopper or jumping on the cardboard blockage within the hopper.

Gwynn Davies-McTiffin Ltd of Ings Mill, Bradford Rd, Batley, West Yorkshire was fined £80,000 with costs of £40,000 after pleading guilty to breaching Section 2 (1) of the Health & Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.

The widow of Mr Brook, Diane confirmed in her Victim Personal Statement that “The lives of myself and our children have been ruined.

“Simon was my best friend, my husband, and our children have lost a wonderful father. We have lost everything.

“Every aspect of my life has been affected. Simon lost his life but I have lost my life too. We did everything together. It feels like my lights have been turned off.”

HSE inspector Andrea Jones, who carried out the investigation added: “The risks of clearing blockages at baling machines are well known in the manufacturing industries, particularly in waste recycling industries.

“Adequate guarding of dangerous moving parts and the provision of safe systems of work including isolating and locking-off machinery are the basic principles for protecting employees.

“Various unsafe methods of clearing blockages were used by several employees over a long period of time. There was no supervision or monitoring by management. This was an entirely foreseeable accident which resulted in fatal consequences.

The Safety Conversation Podcast: Listen now!

The Safety Conversation with SHP (previously the Safety and Health Podcast) aims to bring you the latest news, insights and legislation updates in the form of interviews, discussions and panel debates from leading figures within the profession.

Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Google Podcasts, subscribe and join the conversation today!

Related Topics

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments