Yet another example of the Government spotting a real problem and then passing legislation intended to cure it and making a hugely worse problem. Why does this continually happen-because they consult
To put this in perspective you should read and then print a critical review of the above written by real medical doctors, one being our very own Dr Chris Hanning. He and his colleagues were not commis
Where does it say that employers "HAVE to do a risk assessment" on someone returning to work. This may well be the implied outcome of a return-to-work interview and appropriate pastoral care, but the
It made me laugh, when I thought about a visit to the hospital last year and a sign read: 'If you are suffering from flu symptoms go home immdediately'.
This has not been thought through. There is a possibility of companies with massively compromised workforces, people still at work but not functioning well. Many will hang on at work, especially if
COMAH-site operators who wait until the last minute to review their Safety Reports are missing out on the valuable information this exercise can provide, and could be putting their sites, their workers, and others at risk, warns Caroline Stoker.
Every company that owns and operates a top-tier major-hazard installation will – or should – be aware that, under regulation 8 of the Control of Major Accident Hazards Regulations 1999, they are required to review their Safety Reports “at least every five years”. The key word here is ‘review’; full re-submission of the Safety Report is neither obligatory nor, in many cases, necessary. What many companies fail to appreciate, however, is that reg.8 is much broader then the five-year review; it also requires operators to undertake a formal review of their Safety Report in the following instances:
in response to new facts, or to take account of new technical knowledge about safety;
whenever the operator makes a change to the safety management system that could have significant repercussions, with respect to the prevention of major accidents, or the limitation of the consequences of major accidents to people and the environment; and
in advance of any proposed modification to the establishment or an installation, the process carried out, or the nature or quantity of dangerous substances present, and where that modification could have significant repercussions, as above.
Consequently, the majority of companies wait until the five-year deadline approaches before dusting off their Safety Report and starting the review process – but this could be putting themselves and others at risk.
A change is as good as a risk
The fact is that whenever changes are made to plant, equipment, systems, or personnel, there is always the potential for new associated risk. Most companies understand and have management systems in place to capture the major changes, such as large capital projects, new raw materials, new product introductions, or changes to inventory levels, and hence update their COMAH Safety Reports accordingly. What is more difficult to grasp is that seemingly insignificant changes to plant, people, software, etc, which are not usually captured by the change-management system, can have significant consequences.
Take, for example, a large terminal complex, which submitted its COMAH Safety Report to the Competent Authority two years ago. Since then, very little has changed in terms of new equipment. However, following a failure, they replaced an actuated valve in a tank-feed pipeline with a ‘similar’ one, albeit a slightly different specification to the original. The new one is fail-open on loss of compressed air, whereas the original unit was fail-closed. At the same time, an experienced member of staff retired, and a new maintenance team was contracted.
On the face of it, these seem quite ordinary changes, and quite independent of each other. But look at it in another way: since the new valve is not exactly the same as the one it replaced, it might compromise the original design intent; the replacement for the retired employee may not be privy to the original design and the fact that the valve in question forms part of a Safety Instrumented System protecting against overfill; similarly, the new maintenance team may propagate this error by subsequently replacing other inlet valves to the new specification.
Over time, systems on which the company previously relied and for which it claimed credit in its original COMAH Safety Report no longer offer the same level of risk reduction, the ultimate consequence of which could be escalation of a minor event into a major accident.
Remember the repercussions
So, how do operators successfully identify minor changes, or series of changes, that may have ‘significant repercussions’? And just how significant is significant? The COMAH Competent Authority1 has given a degree of guidance by stating that “a change will have significant repercussions with respect to the prevention or control of major accidents if it changes the nature of the major-accident risks, so requiring changes in the measures taken to ensure that those risks remain as low as reasonably practicable (ALARP)”.
Whether a change has significant repercussions is largely dependent on the degree to which it:
introduces a new major accident hazard;
changes the risk from an existing hazard; or
affects control or mitigation measures (including off-site emergency plans).
Examples of these could be:
changes to the Safety Management System (SMS), such as amending the permit-to-work system;
replacement of staff with third-party contractors;
de-manning and/or combining roles;
changes in procedures; or
plant modifications.
In terms of changes to the Safety Management System, a review should take place as soon as possible after the changes are made. Such changes could include substance changes in terms of type, classification or inventory; the removal or introduction of safety-critical plant; changes to storage facilities or occupied buildings; control-system changes; new suppliers; and so on. In the case of plant modifications, note that reg.8 states that the review must be carried out before the changes are made.
Other factors that could have significant repercussions and therefore need to be incorporated into an updated Safety Report are new facts or knowledge that have come to light since the submission of the last report – for example, key learnings from worldwide events like Buncefield and Texas City, or the reclassification of substances as hazardous, or non-hazardous.
But if no major changes have taken place, does the Safety Report still need to be reviewed? Yes! The original report still needs to be reviewed to ensure that all risks remain as low as reasonably practicable – although it is likely that, following consultation with the Competent Authority, it may not need to be resubmitted, or maybe only in part. Taking a more open and inclusive approach and inviting the Competent Authority to comment on your review process may seem like ‘asking for ‘trouble’ but remember: the fewer changes you make to the Safety Report and the less you resubmit, the quicker and cheaper the review. (It should also be remembered that if risks have been reduced since the original report, this must also be documented.)
Once you have conducted a new risk assessment of your plant and reviewed your existing Safety Report, you must ensure that the report you submit meets the current requirements/expectations of the Competent Authority. To this end, both the Health and Safety Executive and the Environment Agency have produced guidelines for submissions and these can be found on the respective authorities’ websites.
Conclusion
To ensure that your Safety Report remains both current and a ‘living’ document you should, rather than waiting five years, conduct annual or two-year reviews of the report; ensure your company has well-developed change-management procedures, which are robustly adhered to; aim for a culture in your company in which the question is “why isn’t this change subject to formal review” rather than “why is it?”; and finally (and possibly most crucially), don’t see COMAH as a box-ticking exercise – use the knowledge and expertise gained while developing the report to drive your business forward.
Reference
1 The Competent Authority is the HSE and the Environment Agency (in Scotland, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency)
Caroline Stoker is head of regulatory compliance at HFL Risk Services.
EAST COAST MAINLINE COMPANY: Head of Safety and Environment
£60K:
East Coast Mainline Company
As one of the UKs leading rail operators, East Coast Mainline Company is responsible for the safe running of Britain’s premier rail route, the East Coast Main Line. With over 136 departures every day and carrying in excess of 18 million passenger per year
York
WEST SUFFOLK HOSPITAL TRUST: Health and Safety Advisor
Band 5 – £20,710 – £26,839 pa:
West Suffolk Hospital Trust
A well organised Health and Safety professional is required to join the busy Risk Office at the West Suffolk Hospital. This is an exciting and varied role which will suit a motivated person with a passion for health and safety.
West Suffolk
MARSHALLS: CDM Co-ordinator
£competitive + benefits:
Marshalls
Marshalls is one of the UK's leading manufacturers of home enhancement and landscape products for the consumer and commercial markets.
Based Halifax
NORTHERN FOODS PLC: Senior Health Safety and Environment Manager
c£45k plus benefits:
Northern Foods Plc
With revenues of c. £1bn (2008/09), employing around 11,000 employees across 21 of our sites, we are focused around five key categories; Pizza, Biscuits, Ready meals, Sandwiches & Salads and Puddings. Northern Foods is well known for the quality of its fo
Batley, West Yorkshire
COMMONWEALTH WAR GRAVES COMMISSION: HEALTH AND SAFETY MANAGER
Starting at £30,390:
COMMONWEALTH WAR GRAVES COMMISSION
We are the international organisation responsible for preserving the many cemeteries and memorials that commemorate the sacrifices made by the Commonwealth forces in the two world wars. Our work extends across 150 countries around the world.
Maidenhead
PLYMOUTH COMMUNITY HOMES: Health & Safety Officer
£32,000:
Plymouth Community Homes
You will have post-qualification demonstrable experience as a Safety Officer providing operational and strategic health, safety advice to managers and be able to evidence your track record of achievements. You will have a minimum of the NEBOSH Diploma or
Plymouth
SHIRLEY PARSONS ASSOCIATES: H&S Trainers
£30-40k:
Shirley Parsons Associates
A leading training provider is currently looking to expand their team by recruiting 2 H&S Trainers to cover their requirements in the South East.
London / South East
MERSEYSIDE FIRE & RESCUE SERVICE: Technical Officers x 8
Grade 8 £24,646 - £26,276:
Merseyside Fire & Rescue Service
Fire Safety Technical Officers are an integral part of the Legislative Fire Safety Dept assessing risks associated with fire, evaluating fire hazards, advising on fire safety measures, inspecting premises and plans, contributing to fire safety solutions d
Merseyside
SHIRLEY PARSONS ASSOCIATES: H&S Advisor
£30-35k + car/car allowance:
Shirley Parsons Associates
A leading commercial property management company are seeking an individual with 1-2 years experience to be based in Manchester.
Manchester
JAM RECRUITMENT: Safety Case Engineers
Circa £50k:
JAM Recruitment
One of the UK’s leading consultancies now requires nuclear safety case engineers.
Bristol or Derby
JAM RECRUITMENT: H&S Consultant
Up to £45k + flexible benefits:
JAM Recruitment
BRILLIANT CAREER OPPORTUNITY WITH ONE THE WORLDS LEADING CONSULTANCIES.
ARE YOU A DIPLOMA LEVEL HSE PROFESSIONAL? WOULD YOU LIKE TO WORK ON SOME OF THE UK'S MOST INNOVATIVE PROJECTS? IF SO THIS COULD BE THE CAREER CHANGING ROLE FOR YOU...
Central London
THE HSE RECRUITMENT NETWORK: HSE Advisor
£25K-£30K:
The HSE Recruitment Network
You will be working for a progressive manufacturer who are searching for a HSE Advisor
JAM RECRUITMENT: Safety Officer
Negotiable:
JAM Recruitment
One of the regions growing civil engineering companies now requires a safety officer to join their team.
Stone
NORWOOD: Health & Safety Officer
Circa £30,000 per annum:
Norwood
We support people with learning disabilities and children and families in need. We work with individuals to improve the quality of their lives and achieve their goals. Our services are provided to the Jewish community and also to people in the wider
Stanmore, Middlesex
CONVERT RECRUITMENT: H&S Consultant
£25 - £30K + benefits:
Convert Recruitment
Expanding multi-disciplined Consultancy require a candidate to cover work for a major new Retail client in the UK. Candidates MUST have experience in all the following - DDA, Fire Risk Assessments, Consultancy background, CDM and Retail sector. You need n
Midlands
CONVERT RECRUITMENT: CDM-CoOrdinator
£30-£40K + Benefits:
Convert Recruitment
Required for an expanding Property & Surveying Client in the NW: Nebosh Construction, 4-6 years acting as a CDM-C and /or Planning Supervisor, Experience of the public sector projects would be highly desirable, with excellent communication and client faci
Manchester
CONVERT RECRUITMENT: SHE Advisor
£30k-40k + car + bens:
Convert Recruitment
You will hold a minimum of NEBOSH Certificate and must have good 'hands on' experience and ISO proficiency. Only candidates who live permanently near the M4 and have experience of projects installing water, gas and electricity for building developments wi
Berkshire
CONVERT RECRUITMENT: Health & Safety Advisor - Civils
£30k -£38k + car + bens:
Convert Recruitment
To promote high standards of safety performance on civil engineering sites. NEBOSH Diploma calibre required. Extensive site based experience including road works is a must.
Essex
SHIRLEY PARSONS ASSOCIATES: HSE Protection Manager
£55-70k:
Shirley Parsons Associates
A global manufacturer is seeking to appoint a HSE Protection Manager to work across the UK and Europe region.
East Midlands
HSB HAUGHTON ENGINEERING INSURANCE SERVICES LIMITED: Health and Safety Consultant
None specified:
HSB Haughton Engineering Insurance Services Limited
HSB Haughton Engineering Insurance Services Limited is a leading provider of engineering inspection services to an extensive range of clients. As a result of continued growth, we are presently recruiting for an additional Health and Safety Consultant to
Home based, M4 Corridor
SHIRLEY PARSONS ASSOCIATES: H&S / Training Advisor
£25-30k + package:
Shirley Parsons Associates
A leading healthcare provider is currently recruiting for an H&S / Training Advisor to be based in the Midlands and cover a national remit.
West Midlands
WATES: Business Unit Health & Safety Managers
Competitive salary:
Wates
Established since 1897, Wates is the UK's largest independent, family owned construction services company. Our values mean we don't just build great properties, we build brilliant futures too. And because we put our people first, Health and Safety's our n
UK
VION FOOD GROUP LTD: HSE Manager
None specified:
VION Food Group Ltd
VION Food Group Ltd, the UK arm of VION N.V., produces and processes high quality beef, lamb, pork, bacon and chicken as well as a wide range of convenience products such as sausages, cooked meats and added value cooked chicken.
Broxburn
UBM Information Ltd. Place of registration: England and Wales. Registered number: Company number 370721. Registered address: Ludgate House 245 Blackfriars Road London SE1 9UY.
View all comments
