In Court
Home / In Court / Aldi fined £100k for first health and safety conviction

Aldi fined £100k for first health and safety conviction

Supermarket chain Aldi and contractors Wilkinson Maintenance have been fined after an unsecured smoking shelter was blown by the wind, injuring an employee.

Michael Simpson was taking a cigarette break outside Aldi’s Faverdale distribution centre when a gust of wind picked up an unsecured smoking shelter, striking him and pinning him for a few seconds, it was heard in court.

Mr Simpson, received soft-tissue injuries to his back and both arms and still has nightmares about the incident more than a year later, the Northern Echo reports.

Prosecuting lawyer Ros Scott Bell, appearing on behalf of Darlington Borough Council, said the incident could have seen the employee seriously injured or, at worst, killed.

It was heard how Wilkinson Maintenance had moved the metal and perspex smoking shelter to install an emergency exit at the Aldi site. It was left unsecured with Aldi believing Wilkinson would take care of it, while Wilkinson believed it was Aldi’s responsibility.

Both companies pleaded guilty to one charge under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. Aldi was fined £100,000 and Wilkinson Maintenance was fined £20,000. Both were ordered to pay £5,000 in costs.

Aldi’s lawyer Richard Matthews, QC, asked the court to consider the company’s otherwise unblemished health and safety record as a mitigating factor.

He said: “I stress that it is a remarkable achievement to employ 27,000 and to have no previous convictions.

“Following the breach they conducted a swift investigation and every maintenance manager has been given training in relation to it.”

Wilkinson’s lawyer, Matthew Kerruish-Jones, said the company would like to publicly apologise to Mr Simpson.

He said: “As far as mitigation is concerned, there were no aggravating factors and there has been a high level of cooperation between us and the prosecution.”

Judge Simon Bourne-Arton, QC, said the “impeccable character” of both defendants would be considered when setting fines.

Webinar: October Legislation Update 2016

Sign up today for our webinar taking place on Friday 28th October at 11am, presented by leading lawyers Kevin Bridges of Pinsent Masons LLP and Steffan Groch of DWF LLP who will discuss the latest health & safety legislation changes, specifically what these changes mean in practical terms and how they will affect your organisation. Key topics include:
  • The impact of the sentencing guidelines six months on.
  • Brexit and its impact on health and safety.
  • What’s coming into force in the next six months.

Download the health and safety legislation update for October 2016

Leave a Comment

Showing 2 comments
  • steve grimes

    well normally they say smoking kills, but in this instance just soft tissue damage . Oh and “nightmares” ( ahem) we can ese where this is leading cant we,
    £100k fine for this??? ridiculous.

pingbacks / trackbacks